What a compounding rate leaves out of a wine collection's value
The wine collection value estimator does one thing honestly: it multiplies your bottles by their average value and compounds that at whatever rate you give it. That is a useful sum, and it is not the same as what a collection would put in your pocket. This guide works through the difference with one example, using costs that are assumptions you should replace with your own.
The sum the estimator does
Take 60 bottles with an average value of $45.00, so $2,700.00 today. At 4% a year for 10 years:
| Assumed growth per year | Value after 10 years | Paper gain |
|---|---|---|
| 0% | $2,700.00 | $0.00 |
| 2% | $3,291.28 | $591.28 |
| 4% | $3,996.66 | $1,296.66 |
| 6% | $4,835.29 | $2,135.29 |
At 4% the collection is worth $3,996.66 on paper, a gain of $1,296.66. Compounding makes the higher rates look dramatic, which is exactly why the rate is the most dangerous number on the page: it is the one input nobody can know.
The costs the sum leaves out
Two costs sit between a paper value and money. Neither has a standard figure, so here they are as explicit assumptions:
- Storage: suppose professional storage and insurance cost $2.00 per bottle per year. Over 10 years that is $1,200.00.
- Selling: suppose that selling through an auction house or merchant costs 15% of the sale price in commission and fees. On $3,996.66 that is $599.50.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Paper value after 10 years at 4% | $3,996.66 |
| Less selling costs at 15% (assumed) | −$599.50 |
| Less storage at $2.00/bottle/year (assumed) | −$1,200.00 |
| What is left | $2,197.16 |
That is $502.84 less than the $2,700.00 the wine is worth today. Under these assumptions a collection growing at 4% a year loses money once it is stored professionally and sold. Your own costs may be far lower, for example if the wine is kept at home and never sold; the point is that the estimator's "gain" is before all of them.
The rate that only covers the selling cost
Ignoring storage entirely, a 15% selling cost on its own needs the wine to grow by about 1.64% a year for 10 years just to get back to where it started. Check it in the estimator: 60 bottles at $45.00 and 1.64% for 10 years gives $3,176.95, and 15% off that leaves $2,700.41, back at roughly today's $2,700.00.
What else the sum assumes
- Every bottle grows at the same rate. In practice most wine bought to drink does not appreciate at all, and a few bottles may. The guide to averages shows how much that changes the result.
- The bottles are still there. A collection you drink from is not one you can sell in full.
- Someone will buy it. The secondary wine market is illiquid, and condition, provenance and storage history all affect what a buyer will pay.
None of that makes the estimator useless. It is a good way to see what a collection might be worth for insurance, or to understand how sensitive a value is to its assumptions. It is not a forecast.
Work it for your own bottle
The figures above come from the same code the calculators run, so typing these inputs in reproduces them exactly. Your own bottles are the point, though: run your own bottles through the collection value estimator.
Not investment advice. This is arithmetic on assumptions you choose. Wine is an illiquid, unregulated market, past prices say nothing reliable about future ones, and nothing here is a recommendation to buy, hold or sell anything. Speak to a regulated adviser before treating wine as an investment.