Why the oldest red gets the shortest decant
It seems natural that the finest, oldest bottle should get the most ceremony and the longest time in the decanter. It is the other way round. The decanting time calculator gives a young, bold red 90 minutes and a mature one 20: 4.5 times as long for the young wine.
| Style | Decant for |
|---|---|
| Young, bold red (Cabernet, Syrah, Nebbiolo) | 90 minutes |
| Medium-bodied red (Merlot, Sangiovese) | 45 minutes |
| Light red (Pinot Noir, Gamay) | 30 minutes |
| Old or mature red (10+ years) | 20 minutes |
| Fuller white (oaked Chardonnay) | 15 minutes |
| Rosé | 0 minutes |
| Sparkling | 0 minutes |
A decanter does two different jobs
Aeration. Pouring a wine into a wide vessel exposes it to air. In a young, tannic red that softens the grip of the tannins and lets aromas that were tight and closed open up. This is the job that takes time, and it is why the young red gets 90 minutes.
Separation. Over years in bottle, many reds throw a sediment: harmless, but gritty and bitter. Decanting lets you pour the clear wine off it. This job takes seconds, not minutes.
An old wine needs the second job and is put at risk by the first. Its aromas are developed and delicate, and after a long time sealed away from air they can fade surprisingly quickly once exposed. The calculator's note on old reds is explicit: "Decant old reds gently and watch for sediment — pour slowly and stop before the cloudy dregs reach the glass. Older wines fade fast, so serve soon after."
Decanting an old bottle, step by step
- Stand it upright for a day or so beforehand if you can, so the sediment slides to the bottom.
- Open it gently; old corks are often soft, and a two-pronged cork puller copes better than a screw.
- Pour slowly and steadily in one movement, with a light (a torch or a phone screen) under the neck of the bottle so you can see the sediment coming.
- Stop as soon as the cloudy wine reaches the neck, and serve within about 20 minutes.
Decanting a young bottle
Here the aim is air, so do the opposite: pour it briskly, even splashily, into a wide decanter, and give it time. The 90 minutes is a starting point. The calculator's own tool page suggests tasting every 20–30 minutes and serving when it tastes best to you, which is better advice than any number. If a young red still tastes hard and closed after an hour and a half, it will usually keep improving.
The middle of the table
A medium-bodied red gets 45 minutes and a light red 30. Light reds are about fresh, delicate fruit, and too much air can flatten them. A fuller white gets 15 minutes, enough to lift the aromas of an oaked Chardonnay, while rosé and sparkling get none: rosé is made to be drunk fresh, and decanting sparkling wine drives off the bubbles, as covered in the sparkling wine guide.
What about aerators?
A pourer that forces air into the wine as it leaves the bottle is a fast, crude version of the first job. It can help a young red you have not had time to decant, and it does nothing for the second job at all. Never use one on an old bottle with sediment, and never on sparkling wine.
If several bottles are coming to one meal, the times stack up; the dinner timeline guide works backwards from the moment each wine is poured.
Work it for your own bottle
The figures above come from the same code the calculators run, so typing these inputs in reproduces them exactly. Your own bottles are the point, though: look up a decanting time.
These are guidelines, not rules. Every bottle is different, and your own palate is the final judge. Taste as you go and adjust.