Working back from dinner: when to open each bottle
Decanting times are easy to look up one bottle at a time. The trouble at a dinner is that several bottles have different times, they are poured at different points in the evening, and the long one has to be started before you are thinking about wine at all. The answer is to work backwards from when each wine is poured.
Here is a four-wine dinner with guests sitting down at 7:30 pm. The decanting times come from the decanting time calculator and the serving ranges from the serving temperature calculator.
| Course | Wine | Poured at | Decant | Open by | Serve at |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aperitif | Brut sparkling wine | 7:00 pm | 0 min | 7:00 pm | 40–45°F |
| Starter | Oaked Chardonnay | 7:30 pm | 15 min | 7:15 pm | 50–55°F |
| Main | Young Syrah | 8:15 pm | 90 min | 6:45 pm | 60–65°F |
| Cheese | 15-year-old Bordeaux | 9:00 pm | 20 min | 8:40 pm | 60–65°F |
The same evening, in the order you do things
- 6:45 pm: open and decant the young Syrah, for the main at 8:15 pm.
- 7:00 pm: open the brut sparkling wine and pour straight away, for the aperitif at 7:00 pm.
- 7:15 pm: open and decant the oaked Chardonnay, for the starter at 7:30 pm.
- 8:40 pm: open and decant the 15-year-old Bordeaux, for the cheese at 9:00 pm.
The young Syrah is poured third and opened first, at 6:45 pm, because its 90 minutes of air is by far the longest. The old Bordeaux is poured last and opened only 20 minutes ahead, because an old wine needs its sediment left behind, not a long exposure to air; why the oldest red gets the shortest decant explains the difference.
Temperature runs on the same clock
Each bottle also has to arrive at its serving range at the moment it is poured, and that has its own lead time:
- The sparkling wine wants 40–45°F (4.4–7.2°C). Fridge temperature is close enough, so it stays in the fridge, or an ice bucket, until it is opened. It is never decanted.
- The Chardonnay wants 50–55°F (10–12.8°C), warmer than the fridge. Taking it out when you open it, 15 minutes ahead, lets it lose some of the chill while it breathes.
- Both reds want 60–65°F (15.6–18.3°C). If they have been standing in a warm room, give them a short chill before opening rather than after: once a wine is in the decanter it is awkward to cool.
When the plan slips
Dinners run late. A young red that gets an extra half hour in the decanter will almost always be fine, and often better; that is the forgiving end of the table. An old wine left open too long is the risk, which is why it is opened last, and why it is worth tasting it when you open it, so you know whether it needs serving promptly.
If the main course is ready early and the young red has had only half its time, pour it anyway and let the glasses do the rest. Swirling a glass is aeration too.
Make your own
The method is three columns: when each wine is poured, how long it decants, and the difference between them. Write the open-by times on the shopping list, and put the earliest one in your phone.
Work it for your own bottle
The figures above come from the same code the calculators run, so typing these inputs in reproduces them exactly. Your own bottles are the point, though: look up each wine's decanting time and its serving temperature.
These are guidelines, not rules. Every bottle is different, and your own palate is the final judge. Taste as you go and adjust.